Performance Collapse in Packet Networks and Computer Systems

Performance Collapse in Packet Networks and Computer Systems

small Numbers, BIG Consequences

Neil J. Gunther


1  Old Problem in a New Guise
2  Network Failures
3  Internet Congestion
4  Memory Thrashing
5  Related Works

1  Old Problem in a New Guise

In a May, 2011 interview with the CEO of France Telecom, regarding the massive increase in mobile data use and the dangers that creates, Stephane Richard stated:
The real risk of everything is collapse. Nobody utters this loudly enough, but the real issue for the world is a collapse of the network or some local collapses.
We are the people with pipes. We are supposed to invest heavily in pipes in order to bring the capacity which is necessary to sustain the explosion of consumption and usage and data traffic in our networks. At the same time, the people that create this traffic are not really incentivized to manage properly, globally, the traffic. There is an unbalance in the overall system, which in our view is a major problem.
As outlined below, the mathematical tools for analyzing such important and difficult network capacity problems (some of which I helped to develop [2,4,6]), have been around for about 25 years.
A more detailed treatment is presented in Part III of my book The Practical Performance Analyst.

2  Network Failures

The failure of important communcation networks over the last decade has become all too familiar. The entire AT&T phone system was brought to its knees in 1990 by a software bug that escaped the QA process. And a similar problem arose in AT&T frame-relay network on April 14, 1998 that shut down bank ATMs and other business activities. These are examples of sudden, but hard failures, due to "programming" errors of one kind or another.

3  Internet Congestion

What is not so obvious is, that a computer network can become degraded very suddenly even though the average traffic load on the network remains constant. This sudden congestion manifests itself as a spontaneous collapse in performance (seen as orders-of-magnitude drop in packets/second delivered) or a concomitant increase in packet delay. Such effects have been seen on the internet since 1986 and led to the implementation of the slow start congestion avoidance algorithm for TCP/IP networks more than 10 years ago. The same algorithm that was intended to avoid high packet latency is now responsible for latency overhead for HTTP in the world wide web. Some internet researchers suggest we may be facing a possible deja vu all over again.
Clearly, it is important to understand the dynamics of this kind of performance collapse, and oscillation, so as to choose avoidance strategies that are least sensitive to changes in network usage. How can we picture the sudden onset of this kind of performance collapse? For that, we turn to a more familiar but related problem; virtual memory thrashing.

4  Memory Thrashing

The state of computer system or network is parameterized in conventional queueing models by the average length of the fluctuating queues corresponding to contention at each of the physical resources (e.g., processor, disk, memory, or router) being modeled. A typical closed-circuit queueing model for a time-share computer system is shown in the following diagram.
Figure 1: Queueing network model of a virtual memory computer system
Under certain conditions, however, queues can fluctuate about more than one stable average length i.e., some queues can have two stable lengths: "short" and "long" (for some value of short and long). A "long" queue means that it will take a long time to have any request serviced (on average). More importantly, the presence of two stable queue lengths implies that the system may move dynamically between these stable queue lengths in some way. It turns out that this transition between stable queue lengths can occur very suddenly in real computer systems, e.g., the onset of "thrashing" in virtual memory computers usually happens without warning.
Since the queue-lengths are a measure of such important macroscopic performance metrics as response time, it would be very useful to have both a qualitative and a quantitative understanding of the dynamics of these large fluctuations or large transients. In conventional modeling approaches, large transients are difficult to capture and calculate.
This tutorial will survey a variety of modeling techniques applied to the problems of stability in computer performance analysis. One such method (the Path-Integral or Instanton technique) is due to the author and is presented in more detail in PART III of the book The Practical Performance Analyst. The motivation for the approach is depicted schematically in the following diagram which shows the relationship between the conventional queueing model throughputs and a "hidden" mean potential function which controls the stability of the queueing system. The dynamics of the transition to the state of degraded performance can be easily visualized as the movement of a "ball bearing" between two "valleys."
Figure 2: The relatiobship between the queueing model parameters and the transition control surface
With this intuitive representation in place, Dr. Gunther then recognized that the problem of estimating the mean time to transition (MTTT) is analogous to calculating the decay rate of an atom in quantum mechanics; he was sure all that it would come in handy one day! At this level of detail the "ball bearing" behaves stochastically; more like speck of dust jiggling in water (i.e., like Brownian motion). The form of the MTTT estimator derived from the path integral is given by the formula:

N → ∞ 
E(Tc)  ∼ K eN S0
which states that in the limit of a large number of sources, N, the expected time Tc to reach the top of the hill at Xc, starting from the valley at X0, is determined by three constants:
  1. N, the system size, e.g., the number of routers in a network,
  2. S0, the cost of climbing the hill, which is also related to the shape in Figure 2),
  3. K, a prefactor determined formally by the integration measure in the path integral (not discussed here).
A significant virtue of this formula is that it enables fast numerical computation (as opposed to doing matrix inversions or long simulations) and could therefore be used in a predictive way to the reshape of the hill dynamically, so as to ensure optimal performance without the risk of actual collapse. Such a scheme has been considered for admission control in ATM networks.

5  Related Works

Related approaches to estimating the MTTT have included: Catastrophe Theory, and the theory of Large Deviations in mathematical statistics. A fairly readable account of the application of large deviations concepts to real communications networks can be found in High-Performance Communications Networks by Walrand and Varaiya.
In 1997, Dr. Gunther was invited to present his path-integral approach at the Workshop on Fluctuations, Escape, and Optimal Control, Univeristy of Arizona, and UC Berkeley.
To see a 3D rendering of the stability concepts just discussed, you are invited to stare at the logo on the Performance Dynamics home page.
The formal mathematics supporting these intuitive arguments can be found in the following papers:


NJG, "A New Interpretation of Computer System Instabilities," Proc. ACM SIGMETRICS Conference, May 24-27, Santa Fe, New Mexico (1988)
NJG, "Path Integral Methods for Computer Performance Analysis," Information Processing Letters, 32(1): 7-13 (1989) (5MB scanned PDF)
NJG, "Instanton Techniques for Queueing Models of Large Computer Systems: Getting a Piece of the Action," Invited paper presented at SIAM Conference on Applied Probability in Science and Engineering, March 1990 New Orleans, Louisiana (1990)
NJG, "Bilinear Model of Blocking Transients in Large Circuit-Switching Networks," In PERFORMANCE '90, Proceedings of the 14th IFIP WG 7.3 International Symposium on Computer Performance Modelling, Measurement and Evaluation, Edinburgh, Scotland, 12-14, September, Amsterdam: North-Holland. 175-189 (1990)
NJG, "Performance Pathways: The Path Integral View of Computer System Stability," Performance Evaluation Review, 17(2): 50 (1990)
NJG and J. G. Shaw, "Path Integral Evaluation of ALOHA Network Transients," Information Processing Letters, 33(6): 289-295 (1990)

File translated from TEX by TTH, version 3.81.
On 26 Oct 2017, 09:24.